A conflict of interest (COI) in healthcare occurs when a person or organization involved in medical decision-making, such as a doctor, researcher or healthcare administrator, has a secondary interest (financial, professional or personal) that could compromise or influence their objectivity and clinical judgment.
This secondary interest has the potential to affect decisions about diagnosis, treatment, or research in a way that’s not aligned with the best interests of the patient or public health.
Key Components of a Conflict of Interest
Key elements of a conflict of interest include:
- Financial ties, such as relationships with pharmaceutical companies or medical device manufacturers
- Personal or professional relationships that can bias medical decision making
- Institutional interests that influence financial or strategic decisions
Why COI Must Be Addressed
The identification and mitigation of COI in healthcare is critically important because they directly affect the quality of patient care, the integrity of medical research, and the overall trust in healthcare systems.
Here’s why it’s essential to avoid conflicts of interest:
- Protect Patient Health and Safety
When a healthcare provider has financial or personal incentives that conflict with the patient’s best interests, it could lead to recommendations for unnecessary treatments or suboptimal care. This can directly harm patients, either through unnecessary side effects, prolonged treatments, or missed opportunities for better outcomes.
Patients trust healthcare providers to make decisions based on their health needs, not on external incentives. If a physician is influenced by financial or personal gain, it undermines this trust and can result in patient harm.
- Ensure Clinical Objectivity and Best Practices with Evidence-Based Decisions
In healthcare, clinical decisions should be grounded in the best available scientific evidence. COI can distort clinical judgment, leading to decisions based on profit motives or personal interests, rather than sound evidence or best practices.
When decisions are made objectively, based on the best evidence and clinical standards, it ensures optimal outcomes for patients and trust in the system.
- Reducing Healthcare Costs by Avoiding Unnecessary Procedures
COI can lead to overutilization of tests, procedures and treatments that are not medically necessary, inflating healthcare costs for individuals and insurance systems. Unnecessary treatments contribute to the rising cost of healthcare and can create financial burdens on patients, insurers and the healthcare system as a whole.
Mitigating COI can lower costs by ensuring that treatments are based on necessity and effectiveness, not financial incentives.
- Preventing Fraud and Abuse in Healthcare Through Ethical Integrity
COI can open the door to fraudulent practices, such as billing for unnecessary services, overprescribing medications, or manipulating patient data for personal gain.
Addressing COIs protects the integrity of the healthcare system, ensuring that resources are used appropriately and that the system is not exploited for financial gain.
Impact of Conflicts of Interest on Healthcare Systems
COI most directly impact patients, but also have ripple effects on healthcare providers, the broader healthcare system, and society’s trust in medicine. Patients are the primary victims, as COI can lead to unnecessary treatments, misdiagnoses, or biased recommendations, compromising their health, safety, and financial well-being.
Physicians, researchers and healthcare organizations may face ethical dilemmas and reputational damage when COI influence their decisions, undermining their professional integrity. Widespread COI can erode confidence in the healthcare system, leading people to question the objectivity of medical decisions, ultimately affecting public health outcomes.
Role of Compliance Officer in COI Management
The compliance officer helps ensure transparency, ethical decision-making, and accountability, thereby protecting patients and maintaining system integrity. The compliance officer’s role in mitigating COI risk involves:
Monitoring: Ensuring healthcare professionals and organizations disclose any potential COI, particularly financial or personal interests, that could influence decisions.
Policy Enforcement: Implementing and enforcing clear COI policies and procedures, including guidelines for recusal or divestment when conflicts arise.
Education and Training: Providing ongoing education to staff about identifying and managing COI to maintain ethical standards.
Auditing and Reporting: Regularly auditing practices for compliance with COI regulations and reporting any violations to ensure corrective actions.
An Unfortunate Example of a Deliberate COI
In 2015, Dr. Farid Fata was sentenced to 45 years in a federal prison by U.S. District Judge Paul Borman. Dr. Fata, who had built an empire of upscale cancer clinics, intentionally misdiagnosed patients and illegally billed Medicare for the treatment.
He grossly over-treated, under-treated, and misdiagnosed hundreds of patients by telling them they had cancer when they did not. He administered too much or improper treatment to others who did have cancer and continued to give chemotherapy to terminal patients who no longer needed it.
Over $34M in Billings from Fraudulent Treatments
About 550 patients have been identified as victims, with 34.7 million in billings to patients and insurance companies, and 17.6 million paid for work Dr. Fata admitted was unnecessary. Prosecutors say Dr. Fata was notorious for treating all his patients personally and keeping other medical professionals away.
The U.S. Attorney’s office said Dr. Fata, “is the most egregious fraudster in the history of the country, measured not only by the millions of dollars he stole but by the harm he inflicted on his victims.”
This case is one of the most extreme, but it highlights a powerful conflict of interest where financial incentives result in harmful over-treatment of patients. Financial pressure or incentives, whether directly or indirectly tied to volume of procedures, can lead some physicians to recommend unnecessary treatments. These actions exploit the trust of patients, who rely on the expertise of their doctors for decisions that can affect their health, safety, and financial well-being.1
Conflicts Embedded in Medical Guidelines and Standards
A unique and mind-blowing aspect of COI in healthcare that few people realize is how deeply conflicts can be embedded in medical guidelines and “evidence-based” standards themselves, shaping the very definition of disease and thresholds for treatment in ways that drive profit more than health.
When a physician prescribes a statin or a glucose-lowering drug, it feels like a purely clinical decision. But that decision is based on guidelines often crafted by panels with financial ties to drug manufacturers. Even physicians who believe they’re making objective decisions may be following protocols shaped behind the scenes by corporate influence.
Medical guidelines—the foundation of diagnosis and treatment—are often written by experts who have financial ties to pharmaceutical or device companies whose products benefit from more liberal definitions of disease.
The assumption is that practitioners and patients need guidance for medical decision making. But in many cases, it’s the interests of pharmaceutical and medical device companies subtly shaping the physician’s practice by influencing how diseases are defined. It seems like medicine is in control, but often, industry tailors the rules of the game through guideline panels, research funding and educational influence.
Workforce Awareness Needed to Reduce COI
Members of a healthcare organization’s workforce need to understand what constitutes a Conflict of Interest. COI occur when personal, financial, or professional interests interfere with objective decision-making that affects patient care, research, or organizational integrity.
The workforce also needs to be aware of disclosure requirements, because they must disclose any potential COI to the compliance officer or management, especially financial relationships with outside entities. Workforce members have an ethical responsibility to prioritize patient welfare, transparency and integrity over external interests in all decisions.
How Employees Should Respond to COI Suspicions
If an employee suspects a COI might be an issue, they should promptly report suspicions to the compliance officer, management or through confidential reporting channels. If they are uncertain, the workforce member can seek advice on whether a situation constitutes a COI and how to proceed. This ensures accountability and maintains ethical standards in the organization.
A solid conflict of interest mitigation process is crucial for a healthcare organization because it ensures patient safety, maintains ethical decision-making, prevents financial exploitation, and preserves public trust. Without it, the integrity of care is compromised, risks to patient health increase, and the organization’s reputation and legal standing are jeopardized.
- https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/detroit-area-doctor-sentenced-45-years-prison-providing-medically-unnecessary-chemotherapy ↩︎
Susan is a healthcare compliance leader with over four decades working in a variety of administrative and managerial capacities, including strategic planning, regulatory oversight, revenue cycle risk mitigation, denial and appeal management, privacy and information security, healthcare advocacy, clinical department leadership, provider practice administration, risk management, and quality outcomes. Currently, Susan provides compliance and privacy consulting services to a variety of healthcare organizations, including program implementation, policy and procedure development, compliance and privacy training, and regulatory oversight administration.
Susan is a Certified Internal Auditor (CIA), Certified Healthcare Compliance (CHC), Certified Professional Coder (CPC) and holds a Certification in Risk Management (CRMA).
Download our Latest Whitepaper
Sign-up for our Weekly Newsletter
Schedule a quick overview
- One Compliance Pro’s Regulatory Change Management Process
- Five ways to show how healthcare Compliance delivers value
- 12 key metrics for compliance officers looking to…
- Transforming Compliance to a Department of Yes
- Elevate Healthcare Quality Training: Focus, Not Filler
- Three Strategies to Align Compliance with Revenue Cycle
- Revenue Cycle Management Compliance: Ensuring…
- Navigating Compliance Responsibility: A Foundation…
- Polish Your Quality Education Program
- How the Three Lines Model Strengthens Healthcare Compliance