We keep hearing that COVID-19 changed everything, especially in healthcare. But actual data is pretty thin on the ground.
Mostly, we’ve been hearing anecdotes and stories, many of which are striking. The problem with stories is that they can be unique or unusual, and without the context of clear data, we can’t really tell.
Last week, we got some data.
In May, the Society of Corporate Compliance and Ethics (SCCE) and the Health Care Compliance Association (HCCA) surveyed their audiences on the impact of COVID-19 on their organizations and their work. They received 300 responses, have collated the results, and there are some interesting trends. You can read the full survey results here.
Confirming What We Knew
Some trends are unsurprising, and confirm what we already knew. Survey respondents said they had concerns about the increased risk of compliance failures as a result of the pandemic.
- 77% expected that there would be some increase, or a great increase, in compliance failures.
It’s also unsurprising to see that healthcare saw more of an increase in the number of inquiries being made of the compliance team.
- 42% reported an increase in healthcare
- 30% reported an increase outside of healthcare
Given the number of healthcare-related regulatory waivers and temporary changes that have been issued, this makes total sense.
Positively, collaboration with other departments has been largely unaffected or increased during the pandemic. Compliance is still seen as really valuable to the organization as a whole. The numbers range from 83% to 96% of respondents reporting that collaboration has stayed the same or increased (depending on department).
Differences for Healthcare Compliance
The data also show some surprising trends, specifically related to healthcare compliance.
We know that there has been a huge shift to remote work. The surprising aspect is that the shift is very different between healthcare compliance and compliance elsewhere.
- In healthcare, 60% reported working remotely
- Outside of healthcare, 84% reported working remotely
This gap is big, and hard to explain. Working in healthcare institutions would, presumably, increase the risk of being exposed to the virus. It would have been reasonable to expect that healthcare institutions would do as much as possible to try to get their non-clinical staff set up to work effectively off-site.
What’s even more surprising is that healthcare professionals are less likely to report that the transition to remote work has gone well.
- In healthcare, 47% said the transition had gone better than expected
- Outside of healthcare, 64% said the transition had gone better than expected
The survey doesn’t indicate why this is so. Speculating a little, it could be that the disruption in moving to a remote office, coupled with the sudden influx of regulatory changes, made it more difficult for healthcare compliance professionals to manage their day-to-day work. If this is true, it would also explain why healthcare institutions were less likely to transition compliance professionals to remote work.
There’s another difference between healthcare and other types of organizations, and this suggests things will be difficult for compliance professionals going forward into 2021. In relation to budgets:
- In healthcare, 40% reported a budget reduction
- Outside of healthcare, 31% reported a budget reduction
In short, budget reductions are coming to compliance, as they are going to come to other parts of the healthcare system. (If they aren’t already in place.) As COVID-19 related waivers and suspensions start to expire, compliance is going to have to find a way to do more with fewer resources.